Redirecting to http://dergipark.org.tr/_fragment?_hash=EsLihYzop8NBf84M3h08NcX01qFlUiIR4F9fE-bLUgk&_path=id%3D1355881%26_format%3Dhtml%26_locale%3Den%26_controller%3DApp%255CController%255CSite%255CArticleController%253A%253AesiArticleStats.
Research Article
BibTex RIS Cite

Year 2023, Volume: 9 Issue: 26 - August 2023, 233 - 254, 06.09.2023

Salim Ahmed Rashid Al Musalhi Mohammad Tahir Sabit Haji Mohamma

Abstract

References

  • Albatuwsh, Ab. M, (2014), Altahkim Kawasilat Lihali Almunazaeat Fi Aleuqud Al'iidariati, Risalat Majistir Muqadimatan Fi Jamieat Aleulum Al'iislamiat Alealamiat
  • Bial'urdun. Bin Z, E. M, (2006), Altahkim Fi Aleuqud Al'iidariati, Risalat Majistir Muqadimat Fi Aljamieat Al'urduniyati.
  • Aljunbiuhaa, M. M. Wa MAMDUH M, (2006), Qawanin Al'uwnsitiral Alnamudhajiat Fi Majal Altijarat Alalkitruniati, Dar Alfikr Aljamieii, Al'iiskandiriati.
  • Aleabaadi, M. W, (2007), 'Ahamiyat Altahkim Wajawaz Alluju' 'Iilayh Fi Munazaeat Aleuqud Al'iidariati, Bahath Manshur Fi Majalat Eulum Alsharieat Walqanuni, Aljamieat Al'urduniyati, Aleadad 2, Almujalad 34.
  • Eabd Alhadi, Y. J, (2005), Altahkim Fi Munazaeat Aleuqud Al'iidariati, Dar Wayil Lilnashri, Al'urduni -Eman.
  • Alfarsi, E. Bin H, (2010), Aitifaq Altahkim Wifqan Lilqanun Aleamani, Mujamae Albuhuth Waldirasat Bi'akadimiat Alsultan Qabws Lieulum Alshurtati, Altabeat Al'uwlaa.
  • Allumakia, S. Bt. H, (2011) Altahkim Fi Almunazaeat Almadaniat Waltijariati, Markaz Alghandur, Alqahirati.
  • Almuajadat, M. M, (2002) Altahkim Fi Euqud Aldawlati, Risalat Majistir Muqadimatan Fi Maehad Albuhuth Waldirasat Alearabiati, Alqahirati.
  • Wathayiq Aleuqd Almuahad Li'iinsha' Almabani Wal'aemal Almadaniati, Altabeat Alraabieat Sibtambar 1999.

THE LEGALITY OF RESORTING TO ARBITRATION IN ADMINISTRATIVE CONTRACT DISPUTES: A COMPARATIVE STUDY BETWEEN JORDANIAN AND OMANI LEGISLATION

Year 2023, Volume: 9 Issue: 26 - August 2023, 233 - 254, 06.09.2023

Salim Ahmed Rashid Al Musalhi Mohammad Tahir Sabit Haji Mohamma

Abstract

This study discussed the issue of the legality of resorting to arbitration in administrative contract disputes. Jurisprudence and judiciary rulings being two sources of interpretation of the law, and a statement of the solutions and proposals that jurisprudence came up with, relying on judiciary rulings as the main document in clarifying the realistic application of the issue. The study relied on the inductive method and the analytical method. The study concluded the following results: The Jordanian legislator did not clearly and explicitly stipulate, just as the Omani legislator did, explicitly stipulate the permissibility, but there is evidence confirming the permissibility of arbitration in administrative contracts with the Jordanian legislator in other laws, such as the Jordanian Judicial Independence Law No. (29) of 2014 According to Article (17) and paragraph (b), as well as the new Jordanian Investment Law No. (30) of 2014 according to Article (43), which explicitly stated that it is permissible to resort to arbitration in investment contracts, which are a type of administrative contract. The jurists differed about the legality of arbitration in administrative contracts, some of them supported arbitration in administrative contracts and some of them opposed. The researcher believes that not saying that it is permissible to resort to arbitration in administrative contracts; It does not keep pace with what is required by reality and the development of the economy of countries, so the legislator may set red lines that the arbitral award cannot cross, otherwise the ruling will be considered null and unrecognized, such as not addressing what affects public order and other controls, as some of the legislations under study did.

Keywords

dispute arbitration administrative contracts Omani legislation Jordanian legislation

References

  • Albatuwsh, Ab. M, (2014), Altahkim Kawasilat Lihali Almunazaeat Fi Aleuqud Al'iidariati, Risalat Majistir Muqadimatan Fi Jamieat Aleulum Al'iislamiat Alealamiat
  • Bial'urdun. Bin Z, E. M, (2006), Altahkim Fi Aleuqud Al'iidariati, Risalat Majistir Muqadimat Fi Aljamieat Al'urduniyati.
  • Aljunbiuhaa, M. M. Wa MAMDUH M, (2006), Qawanin Al'uwnsitiral Alnamudhajiat Fi Majal Altijarat Alalkitruniati, Dar Alfikr Aljamieii, Al'iiskandiriati.
  • Aleabaadi, M. W, (2007), 'Ahamiyat Altahkim Wajawaz Alluju' 'Iilayh Fi Munazaeat Aleuqud Al'iidariati, Bahath Manshur Fi Majalat Eulum Alsharieat Walqanuni, Aljamieat Al'urduniyati, Aleadad 2, Almujalad 34.
  • Eabd Alhadi, Y. J, (2005), Altahkim Fi Munazaeat Aleuqud Al'iidariati, Dar Wayil Lilnashri, Al'urduni -Eman.
  • Alfarsi, E. Bin H, (2010), Aitifaq Altahkim Wifqan Lilqanun Aleamani, Mujamae Albuhuth Waldirasat Bi'akadimiat Alsultan Qabws Lieulum Alshurtati, Altabeat Al'uwlaa.
  • Allumakia, S. Bt. H, (2011) Altahkim Fi Almunazaeat Almadaniat Waltijariati, Markaz Alghandur, Alqahirati.
  • Almuajadat, M. M, (2002) Altahkim Fi Euqud Aldawlati, Risalat Majistir Muqadimatan Fi Maehad Albuhuth Waldirasat Alearabiati, Alqahirati.
  • Wathayiq Aleuqd Almuahad Li'iinsha' Almabani Wal'aemal Almadaniati, Altabeat Alraabieat Sibtambar 1999.

Year 2023, Volume: 9 Issue: 26 - August 2023, 233 - 254, 06.09.2023

Salim Ahmed Rashid Al Musalhi Mohammad Tahir Sabit Haji Mohamma

Abstract

References

  • Albatuwsh, Ab. M, (2014), Altahkim Kawasilat Lihali Almunazaeat Fi Aleuqud Al'iidariati, Risalat Majistir Muqadimatan Fi Jamieat Aleulum Al'iislamiat Alealamiat
  • Bial'urdun. Bin Z, E. M, (2006), Altahkim Fi Aleuqud Al'iidariati, Risalat Majistir Muqadimat Fi Aljamieat Al'urduniyati.
  • Aljunbiuhaa, M. M. Wa MAMDUH M, (2006), Qawanin Al'uwnsitiral Alnamudhajiat Fi Majal Altijarat Alalkitruniati, Dar Alfikr Aljamieii, Al'iiskandiriati.
  • Aleabaadi, M. W, (2007), 'Ahamiyat Altahkim Wajawaz Alluju' 'Iilayh Fi Munazaeat Aleuqud Al'iidariati, Bahath Manshur Fi Majalat Eulum Alsharieat Walqanuni, Aljamieat Al'urduniyati, Aleadad 2, Almujalad 34.
  • Eabd Alhadi, Y. J, (2005), Altahkim Fi Munazaeat Aleuqud Al'iidariati, Dar Wayil Lilnashri, Al'urduni -Eman.
  • Alfarsi, E. Bin H, (2010), Aitifaq Altahkim Wifqan Lilqanun Aleamani, Mujamae Albuhuth Waldirasat Bi'akadimiat Alsultan Qabws Lieulum Alshurtati, Altabeat Al'uwlaa.
  • Allumakia, S. Bt. H, (2011) Altahkim Fi Almunazaeat Almadaniat Waltijariati, Markaz Alghandur, Alqahirati.
  • Almuajadat, M. M, (2002) Altahkim Fi Euqud Aldawlati, Risalat Majistir Muqadimatan Fi Maehad Albuhuth Waldirasat Alearabiati, Alqahirati.
  • Wathayiq Aleuqd Almuahad Li'iinsha' Almabani Wal'aemal Almadaniati, Altabeat Alraabieat Sibtambar 1999.
There are 9 citations in total.

Details

Primary Language Arabic
Subjects Sociology of Law
Journal Section Articles
Authors

Salim Ahmed Rashid Al Musalhi

Mohammad Tahir Sabit Haji Mohamma

Early Pub Date September 6, 2023
Publication Date September 6, 2023
Submission Date June 13, 2023
Published in Issue Year 2023 Volume: 9 Issue: 26 - August 2023

Cite

EndNote Al Musalhi SAR, Haji Mohamma MTS (September 1, 2023) THE LEGALITY OF RESORTING TO ARBITRATION IN ADMINISTRATIVE CONTRACT DISPUTES: A COMPARATIVE STUDY BETWEEN JORDANIAN AND OMANI LEGISLATION. IJASOS- International E-journal of Advances in Social Sciences 9 26 233–254.
 Download Cover Image

Contact: ijasosjournal@hotmail.com

17922

The IJASOS Journal's site and its metadata are licensed under CC BY

Published and Sponsored by OCERINT International © 2015- 2025